INDIA Law and Practice Contributed by: Roopali Singh, Yugank Goel, Aayushi Rout and Sushanth Sanjay, Vritti Law Partners
notice is a precondition to bind parties in a repre- sentative action. • Execution Against Non-Parties: Representative decrees under the CPC are executed against defendants in the same way as individual decrees. However, execution against non-parties raises particular problems. Courts have therefore devel- oped doctrines to balance the binding efficacy of collective decrees, while protecting the interests of unnamed persons. Practitioners must plan enforce- ment by (i) naming defendants with identifiable assets; (ii) obtaining specific monetary orders ame- nable to execution; and (iii) taking steps to secure interlocutory attachments where necessary. • Continuous Supervision: When collective relief involves long-term or public law obligations, the courts have adopted supervisory measures to secure compliance such as in • M. C. Mehta v Union of India , AIR 1988 SC 1037, where the Supreme Court ordered a continuing mandamus and appointed monitoring committees to ensure sustained remedial action. This meas- ure is most often used where the remedy involves long-term rehabilitation or complex distribution of funds. • Settlement: The treatment of settlements in mass litigation demonstrates the courts’ insistence on supervising such settlements. The settlement process followed in Union Carbide Corporation v Union of India , AIR 1992 SC 317, the Bhopal Gas tragedy matter, however, provides a cautionary example where the court’s engagement with settle- ment terms, and the subsequent public scrutiny of the distribution of funds, highlighted the need for clear settlement approval processes and credible claims administration. • Contempt and Penal Enforcement: Where collec- tive remedies require action by public authorities, execution of policy directives, payment of com- pensation, environmental remediation, etc, Indian courts regularly invoke contempt powers to secure compliance. • Cross-Forum and Cross-Border Enforcement: Col- lective claims sometimes involve multiple forums and foreign defendants. Where defendants or assets are transnational, enforcement planning before judgment, by identifying attachable domes- tic assets, obtaining preservatory orders, and
securing jurisdictional footholds, becomes essen- tial. While Indian courts will enforce foreign decrees recognised under domestic law, practical recovery in transnational disputes requires tactical litigation choices and, increasingly, co-operation with foreign regulators and courts.
4. Legislative Reform 4.1 Policy Development
Historically, collective redressal, whether under Order I Rule 8 of the CPC, Section 245 of the Companies Act, the NGT Act, or the constitutional framework for PILs, has evolved in response to fragmented harms and systemic governance failures. The government of India’s Digital India and National Online Dispute Resolution (“ODR”) initiative spear- headed by the NITI Aayog is at the forefront of policy development, envisioning technology-enabled aggre- gation of similar grievances and algorithmic cluster- ing of disputes, allowing thousands of consumers or investors with identical issues to obtain redress col- lectively and efficiently. The ODR initiative proposes integration of artificial intelligence tools for triaging complaints, automating notice issuance, and moni- toring compliance with tribunal orders. Policy emphasis has also shifted from traditional con- sumer transactions to the digital marketplace. Follow- ing the Consumer Protection (E-commerce) Rules, 2020, the CCPA has been positioning itself as a pro- active regulator capable of initiating class action-style enforcement against malpractices, such as dark pat- terns, discriminatory algorithms, and unsafe product listings. Environmental collective redress has evolved through both statutory and constitutional channels. The NGT’s suo moto powers, upheld in the Mantri Techzone Pri- vate Limited v Forward Foundation judgment, reflect a policy recognition that environmental harm is inher- ently collective. At a broader level, India’s National Climate Change Policy and LiFE (Lifestyle for Environ- ment) mission promote a significant behavioural shift toward environmentally conscious living and indicate
158 CHAMBERS.COM
Powered by FlippingBook