SPAIN Law and Practice Contributed by: Cristina Alba and José María Rodríguez Hernández, act legal
poration and management abroad respond to valid economic reasons and that effective management is genuinely exercised outside Spain. Tax residence entails the obligation to declare world - wide income for CIT purposes, which means that an incorrect assessment of residence can have a signifi - cant impact on an entity’s finances. 2.6 Definition of Permanent Establishment The concept of permanent establishment (PE) is defined under Spanish domestic law in the NRIT Act, which is the starting point for determining whether a non-resident is taxable in Spain on business profits attributable to a presence in Spain. As a general rule, a PE exists where a non-resident has, on a continuous or habitual basis, facilities or a place of work in Spain through which all or part of its activity is carried on, or where it acts in Spain through an agent authorised to contract in the name and on behalf of the non-resident who habitually exercises those powers. The statutory examples include management offices, branches, offices, factories, workshops, warehouses, mines and construction/installation projects lasting more than six months. In treaty cases, however, the applicable double taxa - tion treaty definition prevails over domestic law. Spain’s treaty PE clauses are generally aligned with Article 5 of the OECD Model, although there are trea - ty-specific variations (for example, on construction thresholds, the wording of specific activity exemp - tions, and the drafting of agency PE provisions). In practice, PE analysis in Spain therefore requires a dual review: domestic law for local qualification and com - pliance, and the relevant treaty for the final threshold and allocation of taxing rights. A notable feature of Spanish practice is the so-called “Spanish approach” to PE, which became particularly visible in the Dell litigation. Spanish courts endorsed a substance-based analysis under which a formal com - missionaire or limited-risk structure may still give rise to a PE where the Spanish entity performs core busi - ness functions and operates under the close direction and control of the foreign enterprise. This approach is often viewed as anticipating, in practical terms, the broader anti-fragmentation and anti-avoidance con -
cerns later addressed in the OECD BEPS Action 7 work. The MLI is also relevant to PE analysis in Spain. In its MLI position, Spain adopted Article 12 (commission - naire arrangements and similar strategies) and opted for Article 13 Option A (specific activity exemptions), which generally narrows the availability of automatic exemptions for preparatory/auxiliary activities and strengthens anti-avoidance rules for agency structures where the relevant treaty partner has made matching choices. By contrast, Spain reserved out of Article 14 (splitting-up of contracts), meaning that this rule does not apply through the MLI to Spain’s covered treaties. As a result, the impact of the MLI on PE risk in Spain must be assessed treaty by treaty, depending on the counterparty’s MLI position and the entry-into-effect status of the relevant provisions. Finally, administrative practice remains important. DGT rulings and tax audit practice often adopt a sub - stance-oriented view of local functions, people and assets when assessing PE exposure, particularly in distribution, commissionaire and service structures. For that reason, PE risk assessments in Spain are typi - cally driven as much by the operational footprint in Spain as by the formal contractual allocation of roles. 3. Taxation of Cross-Border Income 3.1 Income From Immovable Property Spanish taxes apply to income from real estate in Spain, regardless of where the taxpayer lives. How - ever, the laws for residents and non-residents are dif- ferent. Residents People who live in Spain and rent out property are taxed under PIT on the rental income they get, which can be either investment income or business revenue, depending on how organised and active the rental operation is. For PIT purposes, classifying real estate leasing as a business activity means that the rental operation must have at least one full-time employee. Most costs that are directly tied to rental activity can be deducted. Spanish law also states that if you own urban real estate for personal use and do not rent it
432 CHAMBERS.COM
Powered by FlippingBook