MALAYSIA Law and Practice Contributed by: Will Fung, Penelope Gan and Kee Shao Yee, Richard Wee Chambers
A scheme of arrangement is a court-supervised restructuring tool available to solvent and insolvent companies. The company remains debtor-in-posses - sion. While no automatic stay applies, the court may grant restraining orders preventing enforcement. If approved by the statutory creditor majority and sanc - tioned by the court, the scheme binds all creditors within the relevant class. Winding-up is the terminal insolvency process. Upon a winding-up order, unsecured creditors are stayed from proceedings without leave of court. Secured credi - tors generally retain the right to enforce their security. Control passes to a liquidator, who realises assets and distributes proceeds according to statutory priorities. 7.2 Waterfall of Payments Upon a company’s insolvency, distributions are made in accordance with a statutory waterfall under the CA 2016. First, the costs and expenses of the winding up, including the liquidator’s remuneration and legal fees, are paid. Secured creditors holding fixed charges are generally entitled to enforce against their charged assets outside the general pool. Thereafter, preferential creditors under Section 527 of the CA 2016, including employee wages, statutory contributions and certain government dues, are paid in priority to floating charge holders. Floating charge holders rank next, followed by unsecured creditors. Any surplus is distributed to shareholders, though this is rare in practice. In practice, the outcome often depends on asset reali - sation and the nature of security, and in many liquida - tions the payment waterfall is effectively exhausted at the level of secured and preferential creditors. 7.3 Length of Insolvency Process and Recoveries In Malaysia, insolvency proceedings are not swift and not uniformly value-preserving, particularly from the perspective of unsecured creditors. In terms of duration, the most common insolvency outcome, winding-up, typically takes between 12 and 30 months to complete, depending on whether it is voluntary or court order, and on the complexity of the
company’s affairs. Members’ voluntary liquidations of solvent companies typically take from nine months to over two years, depending on the complexity of asset disposal and tax clearance, but insolvent liquidations, especially court-supervised ones, frequently extend well beyond two years due to asset realisation issues, proofs of debt, creditor disputes, and litigation. As to recoveries, insolvency processes in Malaysia do not reliably generate returns commensurate with the company’s apparent value at the point of entry into insolvency. The statutory priority regime under the CA 2016 means that recoveries are heavily skewed in favour of secured and preferential creditors. Secured creditors generally recover a substantial portion of their exposure where security is properly constitut - ed and enforceable. By contrast, unsecured credi - tors often receive minimal distributions, particularly where assets are fully encumbered or where realisa - tion costs significantly erode the estate. Book value or balance-sheet solvency at entry rarely translates into equivalent cash recoveries once liquidation expenses, preferential claims, and enforcement inefficiencies are taken into account. 7.4 Rescue or Reorganisation Procedures Other Than Insolvency Malaysia does not provide a binding company res - cue mechanism outside formal statutory processes under the Companies Act 2016. There is no purely out-of-court regime that grants an automatic morato - rium or allows a majority of creditors to impose terms on dissenting creditors. Where a stay or cramdown is required, companies must use court-supervised restructuring procedures. In practice, distressed companies pursue consensual workouts with lenders through contractual arrange - ments such as standstills, maturity extensions, cov - enant resets, debt-to-equity conversions or new funding. These arrangements depend on creditor con - sent and do not bind dissenters. Co-ordinated bank restructurings may be facilitated through the Corpo - rate Debt Restructuring Committee, and listed issuers may be subject to the PN17 framework under Bursa Malaysia, but both remain non-statutory and do not themselves impose binding outcomes without formal court processes.
143 CHAMBERS.COM
Powered by FlippingBook