SPAIN Law and Practice Contributed by: Antonio Paredes, Carlos Saldaña, Manuel Martínez and Román Mejías, ZADAL
5.7 Rules Governing the Priority of Competing Security Interests and/or Claims Multiple Liens and Priority of Security Interests Spanish law generally allows multiple layers of secu - rity over the same asset, particularly in the form of first, second and lower-ranking mortgages, and even equal-ranking mortgages in appropriate structures. Priority for registered security (such as real estate and certain registrable movable security) is typically driven by the order of registration, so earlier regis - trations rank ahead of later ones. For pledges and assignments that do not rely on a public registry, prior - ity is usually driven by the perfection mechanics used (eg, possession/control arrangements, and, in some cases, notice to the relevant obligor), which is why “how the security is implemented” matters as much as “what security is granted”. Priority of Claims and Competing Creditors in Insolvency In an insolvency scenario, Spanish law applies a statu - tory ranking of claims, and security holders typically benefit from a special privilege over the relevant col - lateral (generally up to the collateral’s value), with any shortfall treated as unsecured. This means that, while security priority is important, outcomes also depend on claim classification and insolvency mechanics (including how value is allocated between secured and unsecured portions). Additionally, certain claims can be structurally or statutorily advantaged (for example, some public or employee-related claims), so Spanish documentation and diligence often focus on ensuring the security is both properly perfected and resilient under insolvency scrutiny. Subordination Tools and Enforceability of Contractual Priority Subordination is commonly achieved through a mix of structural and contractual tools. Typical approaches include: • structural subordination (eg, HoldCo debt sitting behind OpCo debt because cash must travel up the group); • contractual subordination and intercreditor arrangements (payment blockages, turnover provi - sions, enforcement standstills, and agreed water - falls between tranches); and
• statutory subordination risks, particularly for claims held by “specially related parties” (eg, certain shareholders/directors), which can affect how shareholder or affiliate debt is treated in insolvency. As to whether contractual subordination “survives” insolvency, the practical answer is yes, but not as a blank cheque: Spanish insolvency remains anchored in mandatory statutory ranking, so documentation must be drafted to work with (not against) that frame - work. Recent reforms have moved practice toward greater recognition of certain creditor-to-creditor priority arrangements in insolvency, but the safest approach remains clear intercreditor drafting, careful perfection and a structure that does not depend solely on private ordering to override insolvency rules. 5.8 Priming Liens and/or Claims Priming Liens and Claims That Can Rank Ahead of a Lender Priority in Spain is generally driven by perfection and registration, but certain claims can still prime or dilute recoveries. The main examples are asset-linked statu - tory tax protections (eg, certain local real estate tax exposures), insolvency priorities (estate and privileged claims), and practical priming through rights of reten - tion or set-off, particularly at the account bank level. Mitigants and Common Second-Lien Intercreditor Terms Lenders mitigate these risks through diligence and contractual controls (registry/tax checks, consents/ notices, negative pledge and tax/social security upkeep covenants) and cash/account control to reduce set-off and secure collections, sometimes using escrows/holdbacks for legacy issues. Sec - ond-lien structures are typically managed through a bespoke intercreditor agreement covering payment waterfalls and turnover, junior standstill and senior control, voting and “sacred rights”, caps on senior debt/baskets, and clear release and amendment
mechanics to limit inter-tranche disputes. 5.9 Cash Pooling and Hedging/Cash Management Obligations Cash Pooling in Spain
Cash pooling (physical or notional) is widely used by Spanish corporate groups and is typically document -
239 CHAMBERS.COM
Powered by FlippingBook