SPAIN Law and Practice Contributed by: Antonio Paredes, Carlos Saldaña, Manuel Martínez and Román Mejías, ZADAL
7.3 Length of Insolvency Process and Recoveries Timing and Recoveries in Spanish Insolvency Formal insolvency proceedings in Spain often take two to four years, especially in complex cases or where claim disputes and sale-related litigation arise, while pre-insolvency restructuring plans can be com - pleted in a few months if creditor support is secured. In terms of outcomes, recoveries rarely reflect initial going-concern value: secured creditors typically per - form better than others, but delays, costs and asset depreciation often erode returns, while unsecured creditors usually recover only a small portion and subordinated creditors rarely, if ever, receive payment. 7.4 Rescue or Reorganisation Procedures Other Than Insolvency Out-of-Court Rescue Options Spain has limited standalone rescue tools outside formal restructuring or insolvency. In practice, out-of- court rescues are usually consensual refinancings with financial creditors, supported by standstill arrange - ments and amendments or maturity extensions, but they are purely contractual and generally cannot bind dissenting creditors. When Formal Processes are Needed Although recent reforms have strengthened pre-insol - vency frameworks, binding effects on non-consenting creditors typically require court-supervised restructur - ing proceedings. As a result, out-of-court solutions work best for companies with simple capital struc - tures and a co-operative creditor base, and are less effective where creditors are fragmented or enforce - ment pressure is high. 7.5 Risk Areas for Lenders Key Insolvency Risks for Lenders From a lender’s perspective, the main Spanish insol - vency risks include clawback of pre-insolvency trans - actions, limits on enforcement, and potential rechar - acterisation or subordination of claims. Security or guarantees granted within the statutory look-back period may be challenged if considered detrimental to the insolvency estate, especially where they secure pre-existing debt or involve related parties, and cer - tain payments made shortly before insolvency can also be vulnerable to avoidance.
7.6 Transactions Voidable Upon Insolvency Clawback Regime and Key Exceptions Spanish insolvency law includes a broad two-year clawback regime: acts carried out by the debtor in the two years before the insolvency declaration can be set aside if they are detrimental to the estate, with detri- ment presumed in common risk cases such as relat - ed-party transactions, early repayment of unmatured debt, or granting new security for pre-existing obliga - tions. Actions are typically brought by the insolvency administrator (and in some cases by creditors), and a successful claim renders the act ineffective against the estate and requires restoration of the transferred assets or value. The law also recognises important exceptions, nota - bly ordinary-course transactions at market terms, certain security/payments linked to public claims and specific protected arrangements. These protections include FOGASA-related security, and special regimes for payment/clearing/settlement and derivatives, including financial collateral under Royal Decree-Law 5/2005 (cash/financial instruments collateral, close- out netting and title-transfer collateral), as well as transactions implementing statutory resolution meas - ures for credit institutions and investment firms. 7.7 Set-Off Rights Set-off is recognised in Spain, but insolvency rules apply strict timing limits: in general, only set-off rights that were fully accrued and enforceable before the insolvency proceedings commenced are preserved. If the mutual claims existed pre-filing and the legal con - ditions for set-off were already met, set-off can gener - ally be exercised despite the opening of insolvency. Set-off is not allowed if the conditions were not satis - fied before filing, and it cannot be created or perfect - ed post-filing. In particular, claims acquired after the insolvency filing, or acquired with knowledge of the insolvency for the purpose of set-off, will not qualify, so practical availability turns on whether the require - ments were met pre-insolvency. 7.8 Out-of-Court v In-Court Enforcement A typical out-of-court private credit restructuring in Spain is consensual and creditor-driven, usually com - bining standstill arrangements with amendments or
243 CHAMBERS.COM
Powered by FlippingBook