EGYPT Law and Practice Contributed by: Ibrahim Shehata, Tasneem El-Naggar and Safa Rabea, Shehata & Partners
Focus on compliance for multinational corporations International developments may place pres - sure on multinational corporations operating in Egypt to adhere to higher data protection stand - ards. This is expected to result in more litigation around compliance failures, especially where domestic practices conflict with global obliga - tions. 2.2 Recent Case Law Key Recent Litigation in Egypt Recent privacy litigation in Egypt highlights the complexities of balancing national security con - cerns with data protection rights under the PDPL. A notable case involves the Egyptian Ministry of Interior’s objections and appeals concerning the deletion of a defendant’s criminal record, show - casing the judiciary’s approach to procedural correctness and government accountability. Case overview The case revolves around the Egyptian Ministry of Interior filing multiple objections and appeals related to the deletion of a defendant’s name from the Ministry’s criminal records system. The original ruling, issued by the Administrative Court on 10 April 2021 in Case No 22586 of 74 Judicial Year, required the Ministry to delete the defendant’s criminal record after a prior acquit - tal. The Ministry argued that retaining the record was essential for national security purposes and invoked Article 5 of the PDPL, which exempts personal data held by national security entities from the law’s provisions. Subsequently, the Ministry filed an execution objection in Case No 50804 of 75 Judicial Year on 23 October 2021, seeking to suspend the enforcement of the origi - nal ruling.
Expected Impact of International Developments on Domestic Litigation Adoption of global privacy standards International frameworks such as the EU GDPR are expected to heavily influence domestic privacy litigation in Egypt. The PDPL incorpo - rates many principles from the GDPR, such as transparency, accountability, data minimisation and purpose limitation, and serves as a foun - dation for privacy protection in Egypt. Courts are likely to refer to the GDPR as a benchmark when interpreting domestic laws, especially in cases involving cross-border data handling or advanced technologies. Influence on AI and emerging technologies Global discussions on responsible AI and data protection, led by organisations like UNESCO and the OECD, are expected to shape litiga - tion involving advanced technologies in Egypt. The Egyptian Charter for Responsible AI, which incorporates insights from international stand - ards, may guide court decisions on privacy dis - putes related to AI. Increase in cross-border data disputes As Egypt integrates further into the global digital economy, litigation involving cross-border data transfers is expected to increase. International treaties and bilateral agreements will likely play a significant role in shaping court judgments in cases involving multinational corporations or foreign entities. Rising consumer expectations Exposure to international privacy standards such as the GDPR is expected to raise consum - er awareness of privacy rights. This heightened awareness will likely lead to increased litigation, with individuals demanding stricter compliance with domestic privacy laws.
109 CHAMBERS.COM
Powered by FlippingBook