ENGLAND & WALES Law and Practice Contributed by: John Kaye and Piers Desser, Carson Kaye
Authorities exercise broad discretion in deciding whether and how to proceed, guided by evidential suf - ficiency and public interest tests. Factors include the seriousness of the conduct, the role of senior manage - ment, self-reporting, co-operation and the strength of compliance programmes. Regulators and prosecu - tors also consider proportionality, deterrence and the impact on stakeholders when selecting outcomes. 6.2 Sanctions and Sentencing Individuals convicted of financial crime may face imprisonment, significant fines, confiscation of crimi - nal proceeds under POCA and director disqualifica - tion under the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986. Sentences vary widely: fraud and bribery offences can attract multi-year custodial terms, particularly where there is abuse of trust or substantial loss. Individu - als may also be subject to ancillary orders, including compensation and serious crime prevention orders. Corporate entities face unlimited fines, confisca - tion orders, and mandatory or voluntary remediation measures. In some cases, courts may impose compli - ance monitorships as part of sentencing or deferred prosecution agreements, requiring independent over - sight of internal controls and compliance frameworks. Sentencing is guided by statutory guidelines and case law with key factors including the level of harm, culpa - bility, financial gain and the role of senior management. Aggravating factors include systemic misconduct, obstruction of justice and repeated offending. Miti - gating factors include early guilty pleas, self-reporting, full co-operation with investigators, prompt remedia - tion, and the existence of effective compliance pro - grammes prior to detection. Courts also consider the wider impact on employees, shareholders, and market confidence, ensuring penalties are proportionate while maintaining deterrence. 6.3 Proceeds of Crime Recovery Post-conviction confiscation proceedings are a cen - tral feature of financial crime enforcement and are designed to strip offenders of benefit obtained from criminal conduct.
• Governing legislation – the regime is set out in POCA, primarily Part 2 (England and Wales confis - cation). • Prerequisites – confiscation requires a criminal conviction. The court applies a “benefit” test (total benefit from criminal conduct, whether or not retained) and an “available amount” assessment (realisable assets at the time of the order). There is no strict limitation period, but proceedings are typically commenced after conviction and sentenc - ing. Third parties may assert proprietary interests during the process. • Procedure – confiscation is heard in the Crown Court, usually following conviction. The standard of proof is the civil standard (balance of probabilities). The court relies on prosecution statements of infor - mation, subject to defence response and possible evidential hearings. A receiver may be appointed to realise assets if necessary. • Enforcement – non-payment can result in a default term of imprisonment (for individuals), interest accruing on unpaid sums, and continued enforce - ment action, including the use of enforcement receivers and restraint orders to preserve assets. Civil recovery proceedings under Part 5 of the POCA can run in parallel with criminal proceedings, particu - larly where no conviction is obtained or against differ - ent assets. Asset tracing may also proceed concur - rently. 6.4 Victim Compensation and Asset Recovery Victim compensation is primarily addressed through confiscation and restitution under the POCA. Courts may order compensation from confiscated sums where identifiable losses are established, and victims are given priority over enforcement proceeds. In parallel, victims can pursue civil claims for damages or proprietary recovery. Proprietary claims allow victims to assert ownership over misappropriated assets (tracing) and their sub - stitutes, provided a clear equitable or legal interest is shown. The legislation permits tracing into mixed funds using equitable principles, enabling recovery of proportional shares.
55 CHAMBERS.COM
Powered by FlippingBook