NIGERIA Law and Practice Contributed by: Abubakar Anafi, Larry Nkwor, Justice Uka-Ofor and Ayomide Abiodun, G Elias
• the lower court’s findings are perverse. 10.3 Procedure for Taking an Appeal
sought and obtained by the party raising the new points. For such leave to be granted, the following must be proved: (i) the new points must relate to sub- stantial points of law, whether substantive or proce- dural, which need to be allowed to prevent a miscar- riage of justice; and (ii) the new points do not need further or additional evidence. 10.5 Court-Imposed Conditions on Granting an Appeal The court cannot impose any conditions on grant- ing an appeal. On hearing an appeal, the court may either grant in whole or in part the relief(s) sought in the appeal or refuse the same. 10.6 Powers of the Appellate Court After an Appeal Hearing The appellate court has the powers of the trial court and can make an order that is appropriate in the appeal. After hearing an appeal, the appellate court has power to: • allow the appeal and set aside the decision of the lower court; • order a re-trial or rehearing of the suit; • direct the lower court to consider issues raised by the parties in the suit which the lower court did not consider in its decision; • make an order that the lower court should have made where there are sufficient facts on the record to support the same; or • dismiss the appeal. 11. Costs 11.1 Responsibility for Paying the Costs of Litigation Generally, each party bears the costs of litigation. However, a party may claim and the court may make an award as to costs. The expenses in respect of which costs may be awarded include: • the cost of legal representation and assistance of the successful party, as determined by the court to be reasonable; and
The procedure for appealing is by filing a notice of appeal in the registry of the court that gave the judg- ment. As noted previously, an appellant may have to seek leave of the court in some cases before com- mencing an appeal. Civil appeals to the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court of Nigeria must be filed within three months from the delivery of the judgment, and interlocutory appeals within 14 days of the delivery of the ruling. Criminal appeals must be filed within: (i) 90 days in respect of appeals to the Court of Appeal; and (ii) 30 days in respect of appeals to the Supreme Court of Nigeria. Upon filing a notice of appeal, the registrar of the court below has 60 days to compile and transmit the records to the Court of Appeal. If the registrar fails to do so, the appellant may compile and transmit the records within 30 days of the failure of the registrar to send the records to the Court of Appeal. If the respondent is dissatisfied with the records, the respondent can compile and transmit a supplementary record. The time limits for filing appeals may be extended by the appellate court upon an application made by the appellant, provided that the appellant shows good and substantial reasons for failing to appeal within the prescribed period. The triggering event is the date of delivery of the ruling or judgment by the court. 10.4 Issues Considered by the Appeal Court at an Appeal The issues to be considered on appeal are the issues formulated by the parties from the grounds of appeals distilled in the notice of appeal filed in the court. Those issues will generally arise from the judgment appealed against. By law, appeals in Nigeria are by way of rehearing. Hence, the appellate court must rehear and accord a second consideration to the judgment and proceedings of the lower court to such extent as the grounds of appeal demand. An appellate court would not consider new points raised for the first time on appeal, unless leave is
828 CHAMBERS.COM
Powered by FlippingBook