USA Law and Practice Contributed by: Courtney Scobie, Jack Edwards and Andrea Whitley, Ajamie LLP
7.7 Level of Intervention by a Judge The level of intervention by a judge during a hearing or trial can vary depending on the nature of the proceedings, the specific circumstances, and the judge. The judge rules on legal issues – such as objections to the admissibility of evi- dence – at hearings and at trial. In jury cases, the judge provides jury instructions, which explain the law that the jury must follow when reaching a verdict. The judge maintains order in the court- room, ensuring that proceedings are orderly and respectful. In some hearings and non-jury trials, the judge renders a decision at the end of the proceeding. This may happen when the judge believes there is sufficient information to make a decision. In other cases, the judge reserves judgment to a later date. This may happen for various rea- sons, including when the judge requires addi- tional time to review evidence or legal issues. Judgment may be reserved for days, weeks or even months, depending on the complexity of the case and the judge’s workload. The judge may request additional briefing after a hearing or trial, including on proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law. In jury trials, the judge does not render a deci- sion; instead, the jury renders a verdict. The judge’s role is to manage the proceedings and instruct the jury on the law; however, the ultimate verdict is made by the jury. 7.8 General Timeframes for Proceedings The timeframes for proceedings from the com- mencement of a lawsuit to trial, as well as the typical duration of trials, can vary significantly. Commercial disputes can be influenced by the complexity of the case, by court caseload, and by the parties involved. Cases typically go to trial
between one and three years after the case is filed. Trials can last from a few days to several months, depending on the complexity of the case and the number of witnesses and exhibits involved.
8. Settlement 8.1 Court Approval
In the USA, court approval is generally not required to settle a lawsuit. Parties involved in a lawsuit have the right to voluntarily settle their case at any time before or during trial without seeking court approval. However, there are specific circumstances in which court approval may be required to settle a lawsuit, such as: • class actions; • cases involving minors or incapacitated par- ties; • cases with structured settlements; and • probate matters. 8.2 Settlement of Lawsuits and Confidentiality In the USA, the settlement of a lawsuit can remain confidential if the parties involved agree to include confidentiality provisions in their set- tlement agreement. These provisions are com- monly referred to as confidentiality or non-dis- closure clauses. They are contractual terms that the parties negotiate and agree upon as part of the settlement process. It is important to note that, even though confi- dential settlements are common, there is debate about their social and legal implications. Some argue that they can shield misconduct or dan- gerous products from public awareness, where-
1452 CHAMBERS.COM
Powered by FlippingBook