BRAZIL Law and Practice Contributed by: Arthur Villamil, Villamil Advogados
3.7 Representative or Collective Actions Typically, individuals are not authorised to ini- tiate legal actions on behalf of others, except in instances where collective actions are legally permitted. Such instances include public civil actions, popular actions and collective writs of mandamus. Entities like public prosecu- tors, public defenders, governmental bodies, and specific associations and unions possess standing to initiate public civil actions, address- ing issues like environmental conservation, con- sumer rights, labour rights and other matters of collective interest. Individual citizens may pursue popular actions aiming to nullify acts perceived as harmful to public assets. The term “public assets” is broad- ly defined and covers economic, historical, aes- thetic, touristic, and environmental resources of public significance. The system for collective litigation employs a unique framework where the collective nature of the action and its outcome influence the bind- ing scope of the resulting judgment. Individu- als involved in related lawsuits may choose to proceed alongside a collective action or request a suspension of their individual proceedings to benefit from the outcome of the collective judg- ment. 3.8 Requirements for Cost Estimate Although Brazilian lawyers are not mandated to provide cost estimates for litigation, the Ethical Code of the OAB requires them to convey the potential risks and consequences of pursuing legal action to their clients transparently.
cases where this fails, the court issues a letter rogatory to be processed by the court where the respondent resides. International respondents are served exclusively through the issuance of letters rogatory. Once served, the respondent has 15 business days to submit a defence. This defence should comprehensively cover all potential procedural and substantive arguments, including any fac- tual and legal claims, and must include all sup- porting documentation available at that time. Any counterclaims the respondent wishes to raise must be included within this initial defence. Upon receiving the defence, the court notifies the claimant to file a rebuttal and address any If a defendant does not respond to a lawsuit within the specified timeframe (usually 15 busi- ness days after being served), the court may declare a default judgment. This default judg- ment applies except: • when the claim involves non-transferable rights; • if any co-defendant among multiple respond- ents files a response; • if the allegations are implausible or contra- dicted by existing evidence; or • if the initial complaint lacks a fundamental document needed to substantiate the claims. Despite a default judgment, the defendant retains the right to participate in subsequent legal proceedings, though without altering or invalidating the previous procedural stages. counterclaims as necessary. 3.6 Failure to Respond
169 CHAMBERS.COM
Powered by FlippingBook